Israel News | Zionism Israel Center | Zionism History | Zionism Definitions | ZioNation | Forum | Zionism FAQ | Maps| Edit

Sunday, March 4, 2007

Saudi religious oppression complains of bad press

The Saudi "virtue commission" claims they are getting a bad rap from the foreign press. They are just doing their job, punishing homosexuals, making sure women don't go around cavorting unveiled and evil foreigners don't have freedom of religion. As they note:
On the other hand, I assure you that some non-Muslim expatriates in the Kingdom have sometimes dared to violate and abuse Islamic sentiments at public places. Such people could be penalized according to the law of the Kingdom."
This is the human rights picture revealed in a recent report:
The government has not yet put into practice laws passed in 2000-2002 to protect the rights of criminal defendants. For example, criminal defendants are not informed of the possibility of appointing legal counsel. Lawyers have difficulty obtaining official documents to prepare a defense, although Saudi law stipulates that "government agencies … enable [the lawyer] to attend any interrogation and peruse any relevant documents."
Saudi courts and judicial procedures remain largely closed to the public. Judges in Jeddah in Najran refused a Human Rights Watch researcher access to attend criminal trials in session, notwithstanding article 155 of the 2002 Saudi Code of Criminal Procedure that provides that "Court hearings shall be public." Former defendants frequently allege that judges in criminal trials pronounce guilty verdicts based on little evidence or testimony. Judges did not issue a written verdict in some cases, such as those related to political trials of an alleged uprising in Najran in 2000.
During Human Rights Watch's visit to al-Ha'ir prison south of Riyadh, prisoners reported that they had suffered physical abuse, had remained imprisoned beyond the expiry of their sentences (particularly in the case of foreign prisoners), and had endured unexplained and lengthy delays before or during their trials. Foreign embassies reported delays of weeks or months before being notified of their nationals' arrest.... arrest.
In interviews with roughly 100 Saudi women academics, educators and medical professionals, Human Rights Watch documented how male guardianship of adult women denies women the right to employment, education, health, and freedom of movement. Government policy often explicitly requires male consent for a range of everyday activities....
Foreign workers in Saudi Arabia confront a precarious legal situation. They can only obtain visas through their Saudi employers, who have the power to repatriate them at any time, or to prevent their return home by holding their passports and refusing to sign exit visas. Women migrant domestic workers are particularly at risk of abuse...
Labor abuses are pervasive in Saudi Arabia. These abuses include nonpayment of wages for months or years, long working hours with no days off, and confinement to the workplace. Human Rights Watch also documented several cases of physical abuse, sexual abuse, forced labor, and trafficking of persons....
Saudi authorities routinely detain children suspected of even minor offenses, including vague charges of transgressing "morals," and such children may face solitary confinement and corporal punishment....While children are not tried in adult courts, they may face adult sentences if a judge determines they are considered "grown-ups" (baligh), and such children, even as young as 13, have been sentenced to death.
Commented the virtue Commission:
"What they strive for is to disfigure the shining image of the country and mobilize international public opinion against Saudi society. Unfortunately such negative criticism draws greater attention of both the domestic and international media," he added.
A wonderful country where women are unable to get drivers' licenses and 13 year old kids get the death penalty. Voice your support for this wonderful institution by writing to or on fax 048362261.

Virtue Commission Slams Media Bias
Mahmoud Ahmad, Arab News
Sheikh Suleyman Tuwaijri   
JEDDAH, 4 March 2007 — In an interview with Arab News, the director of the Madinah branch of the Commission for the Promotion of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice, Sheikh Suleyman Tuwaijri, highlighted the good work that the government-run organization carries out in the Kingdom and among other things dismissed Western media allegations that the commission deprives women and non-Muslims of their rights and freedoms.
Sheikh Suleyman Tuwaijri spoke about the highly controversial allegation that the commission denies women their rights. "The commission takes great pains to protect women from being deprived of their rights, and guarantees them total security. It strongly intervenes when men try to harass them or tempts them to gratify their undignified impulses. The commission gives utmost importance to protect women's rights and freedom that are accorded to them by the Shariah," said Tuwaijri.
However, the director added that there are some things, which "are mistakenly claimed to be part of women's freedom such as the immodest exhibition of their body and some other activities considered beyond the permissible limits of moral regulations fixed by Saudi society and the Shariah."
Speaking about this, Tuwaijri said: "They are in fact violations of the rights of other members of society who want to live in a morally chaste and unpolluted environment. Saudi society, unlike other societies, is a society that is keen to steer away from sexually provocative situations."
He added: "Even the Western civilization admits that freedom should have some checks and balances. An individual's freedom should not transgress into the freedom of another and he or she should respect social values."
With human rights groups having visited the Kingdom at the end of last year, the head of the commission commented on a 2005 human rights report that said outrages against non-Muslims in the Kingdom were on the increase.
Describing the report as one fraught with errors, the director said that the report was made without ascertaining facts and without establishing the credibility of sources.
"Non-Muslims undoubtedly have the right to seek legal help in the Kingdom if anyone infringes on their legal rights," he said. "We demand those who made the charges against us to prove their claims. On the other hand, I assure you that some non-Muslim expatriates in the Kingdom have sometimes dared to violate and abuse Islamic sentiments at public places. Such people could be penalized according to the law of the Kingdom."
Sheikh Tuwaijri added that such "timely action" is thus interpreted as "aggression against their religious freedom while their own action amounted to an aggression against the rights of Saudi society."
Before giving further details on the work that the commission carries out, the director wanted to remind readers that the institution represented by the commission is not a novel idea that has emerged in recent times.
"Although known by different names, this kind of institution was present in Muslim societies in bygone days. The corrective and guiding duty was discharged by an official called 'Amil Souk' in those days. It became a government department during the reign of the second Abbasid Caliph Abu Jaafar Al-Mansour (died in 775 AD)," he said.
The modern Saudi commission was established in AH1345 (1927) by King Abdul Aziz, who appointed a senior religious scholar and some assistants to undertake the duty of promoting virtue and preventing vice in Riyadh during the early period of his rule.
In its present form, the commission is a government organization responsible for the social and religious "Islah" (rectification and reform) of Saudi society. "Its head — who has the rank of a minister — is answerable directly to the king."
The commission undertakes primarily the role of correcting, guiding and protecting society from evil influences that allow society to diverge from a Shariah-based lifestyle," said Tuwaijri.
Speaking about the commission's penal action, Tuwaijri said: "The commission takes the appropriate penal measure on the basis of the prescribed instructions for that purpose in a scenario where advice, guidance and taking an undertaking (not to repeat the error) fails. If the offense is very serious, the violator is handed over to the police."
In its role as a guiding agency the commission also organizes lectures at places such as schools, hospitals and jails. "It distributes books and pamphlets besides participating in exhibitions with special stalls to enlighten the public about the functions of the commission. It also sets up youth camps in cities, rural districts and remote areas besides organizing contests for schoolchildren with the aim of popularizing the commission's aims and objectives," said the director.
The commission also strives to detect and pre-empt vice. "It is with this aim that its field staff makes constant rounds in streets and public places looking for violations that come under its jurisdiction. Its officials often inspect shopping centers for banned items and irreligious activities and celebrations," said Tuwaijri.
He added that the role of the commission could be divided into five tasks:
First, taking steps to prevent the growth of deeds and ideologies that pollute the pristine Islamic religious faith, including the prevention of polytheistic trends, innovations and magic. Secondly, maintaining the practice of religious rites in society by insisting on the prompt observation of prayers collectively at mosques, fasting during Ramadan and respecting all visible symbols of religion. Thirdly, maintaining a sense of morality among people and protecting the honor of women by protecting them from being violated or harassed. As part of this function, the commission insists women do not display their beauty in a prohibited manner. It also takes steps to prevent the occurrence of adultery, prostitution, sexual perversion etc. Fourthly, protecting the sanity and soundness of the human mind and intellect by preventing the manufacture and circulation of narcotics and intoxicants. Fifthly, protecting the cultural and ideological identity of society by taking steps to keep deviant books, magazines, publications, tapes and other material from the reach of the public. Such material also includes obscene and pornographic material.
"Society reaps a lot of benefits from the work that the commission carries out. More importantly, the commission strives to spare society from divine punishments as Muslims believe that negligence in fulfilling the commands of the divine law invites Allah's anger and consequential miseries and punishments both in this life and the hereafter," said Tuwaijri.
The director further clarified that the commission is different from the police in the sense that its goal is to see the reformation of people. "The commission keeps a check on criminal violations primarily from a religious point of view and therefore, deals with violations within the stipulations set by the Shariah and makes full use of the potential to give advice and guidance," he said.
He added: "The commission perceives, like the Shariah, that punishment is not the objective in itself but basically a means to achieve the correction and reformation of people who are erring. Punishment is only handed when it is known that society and the person concerned are going to benefit."
Speaking about allegations that commission workers are unqualified, Tuwaijri wondered why some people express doubts about the qualifications of commission's officials when the Saudi government gives special attention to the training of its workers.
"The commission insists that its workers should be upright in character and scrupulously following Islamic values. Their criminal record should be clean for at least 10 years. They should hold a university degree in Shariah Law. After being recruited following a rigorous interview, they undergo strict training. There is a royal order to the effect that a commission worker should be terminated from service if he is convicted or comes under serious suspicion for involvement in a crime," he said, adding that several annual training and orientation courses are organized at three levels for all field and administrative staff.
"For instance, eight training courses were held in Madinah alone bringing the total number of guiding activities to 384 last year. The commission sends its workers to the Institute of Public Administration and to the Institute for the Promotion of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice at the Umm Al-Qura University in Makkah for higher education in this specialized discipline. Some of them are deputed for masters and PhD degrees at various Saudi universities," he said.
Speaking about non-Muslims in the Kingdom, Tuwaijri said that the religious minorities are given their religious rights. "The Shariah does not permit forcible conversion to Islam nor prevent anyone practicing their religious rites at their place of residence or privately without making it a public or collective event," he said.
"It is the duty of such people to respect Islamic symbols and to not publicly violate them. Foreign non-Muslims in a Muslim society should be careful that the practice of their religion is not carried out at the expense of the host society. It is the right of the Saudi society that non-Muslims respect its religious sentiments while visiting the Kingdom," he added.
Tuwaijri also highlighted the fact that the Kingdom's laws are based on Islam and that all Saudi citizens, without exception, are Muslim. "Non-Muslims have come to the country at their own volition on a temporary basis with the full awareness that they need to respect Saudi religious sentiments and social values. The Kaaba, to which all Muslims in the world turn to while praying, and the Prophet's (peace be upon him) Mosque are in this country. All Muslims aspire to visit this land where the two holy cities are situated."
Since the Kingdom is the Islamic holy land there are stipulations in what non-Muslims can do here. Islam is not against non-Muslims practicing their religion per se. If one was to travel to another Arab or Muslim country then one would find non-Muslims practicing their religion there. This has been the case throughout history and when Jews were expelled from Christian Spain, many of them took refuge in Muslim North Africa and the Ottoman lands.
In Saudi Arabia, being the land of the two holy cities, non-Muslims are categorically not allowed to build places of worship or publicly worship, although they may live here. This is no different to the practices of other major world religions who have similar practices. The Roman Catholic faith for example forbids non-Catholics from having their places of worship in the Vatican as this is considered to be a sanctified place.
Tuwaijri also denied that the commission infringes on the rights and freedom of people. "On the contrary it takes steps to guarantee rights of all people. That is why it intervenes when a person's right is being infringed on by another. For instance, when a woman is being lured by a man for some illicit purposes, and thus tempts the woman to violate the moral code, the commission takes action," he said, adding, "It cannot be called an act of depriving the people of their rights."
Another common perception about the commission is that there is a large gap between the body and the younger generation. The director denied there was a serious problem but admitted that some of the youths failed to receive the commission's message in the proper spirit.
"The commission has been striving to bridge this gap through the media and the Internet. It also makes periodic visits to schools and welcomes student delegations to visit its headquarters. The commission also organizes debates and discussion programs for the youth," he said.
He added: "However, it should be remembered that we have a controlling role in society and take an uncompromising stand against the passions of careless and rash youths who will, obviously, be unhappy with our ways."
Speaking about whether the commission arrests people on mere suspicion rather than concrete evidence, Tuwaijri said: "Arrests are made with sound evidence. If any official violates this principle in arresting then this is a crime that he would have to account for. Cases involving suspicion are always handed over to the police."
Denying the charge, particularly from the Western media, that the commission conducts itself in a violent way, the official said most of the violations reported by the commission are settled in a peaceful manner.
"This is clear from the commission's report last year showing that 94 percent of the violators caught were let off with some advice and preaching. A great number of the violations are disposed on the spot without any detention. The commission also endeavors to keep people away from crime by using methods such as the distribution of pamphlets and booklets, organizing contests, road shows and lectures," said Tuwaijri.
He added that the commission also organized a program entitled "Discover Your Fortune" for youngsters in Madinah during the summer. "All of these operations give an insight into how peaceful and civilized the methods adopted by the commission are and disprove the charge of violence against the commission," he said.
"The commission officials are, above all, civilians holding university degrees. They are not trained to use violence. It is illogical to assume that such officials resort to violent operational methods," the official said.
Tuwaijri added that the commission welcomes constructive and objective criticism of its methods and operations. "On the other hand, the negative criticism leveled against it without objectivity, from some countrymen driven by the ulterior motive of discrediting and destroying the commission, is because of their lack of interest in the welfare of their own country and society," he said.
"What they strive for is to disfigure the shining image of the country and mobilize international public opinion against Saudi society. Unfortunately such negative criticism draws greater attention of both the domestic and international media," he added.
Speaking on the achievements of the Madinah branch, the director said the officials of the branch caught 23,000 people involved in various violations last year. About 93 percent of the cases were settled at its offices while the remaining were handed over to other agencies concerned. Expatriates accounted for 68 percent of them. The commission also seized 40,000 pornographic or obscene materials over the past eight months. The department also organized 708 guidance programs besides distributing 3.5 million booklets and pamphlets.
Tuwaijri stressed the importance of improving the body. "The commission needs to further develop like any other government department. It should update its performance in order to keep pace with the changing times. The commission's head office is striving for it," he said
The director requested a fair and balanced approach when judging the commission instead of giving credence to hostile reports ignoring the positive aspects. The commission can be contacted via e-mail or on fax 048362261.

Copyright - Original materials copyright (c) by the authors. Originally posted at Please do link to these articles, quote from them and forward them by email to friends with this notice. Other uses require written permission of the author.


Post a Comment

<< Home

Subscribe to
email newsletter for this site and others

Powered by

Feedblitz subcription
To this Blog only

You can receive our articles by e-mail. For a free subscription, please enter your e-mail address:

Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz

Web Logs & Sites

This Site

Zionism & Israel
Zionation Web Log
IMO Web Log (Dutch)

ZI Group
Zionism-Israel Pages
Israël-Palestina.Info (Dutch & English)
Israël in de Media
MidEastWeb Middle East News and Views
MidEastWeb Middle East Web Log

Brave Zionism
Israel: Like this, as if
Israel & Palestijnen Nieuws Blog

Friends and Partners
EinNews Israel
Israel Facts
Israel Proud Adam Holland
Middle East Analysis
Irene Lancaster's Diary
Middle East Analysis
Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
Israel Facts (NL)
Cynthia's Israel Adventure
Jeff Weintraub Commentaries and controversies
Meretz USA Weblog
Pro-Israel Bay Bloggers
Simply Jews
Fresno Zionism
Anti-Racist Blog
Sharona's Week
Z-Word Blog
Jewish State
Take A Pen - Israel Advocacy
Zionism on the Web
ZOTW's Zionism and Israel News
Zionism On The Web News
ZOTW's Blogs
Christian Attitudes
Dr Ginosar Recalls
Questions: Zionism anti-Zionism Israel & Palestine
Southern Wolf
Peace With Realism
Sanda's Place
Liberal for Israel
Realistic Dove
Blue Truth
Point of no Return
Christians Standing With Israel
Christians Standing With Israel - Blog

Encylopedic Dictionary of Zionism and Israel
Middle East Encyclopedia
Zionism and its Impact
Zionism & the creation of Israel
Zionism - Issues & answers
Maps of Israel
Christian Zionism Resources
Christian Zionism
Albert Einstein
Gaza & the Qassam Victims of Sderot
Zionist Quotes
Six Day War
Jew Hatred
Learn Hebrew
Arab-Israeli Conflict
International Zionism

Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel
Israel Boycott
Boycott Israel?
Amnesty International Report on Gaza War
Boycott Israel?
Dutch Newspaper Reporting: A Study of NRC Handelsblad
Hamas (Dutch)
Dries van Agt (Dutch)
Isfake lobby

At Zionism On the Web
Articles on Zionism
Anti-Zionism Information Center
Academic boycott of Israel Resource Center
The anti-Israel Hackers
Antisemitism Information Center
Zionism Israel and Apartheid
Middle East, Peace and War
The Palestine state
ZOTW Expert Search
ZOTW Forum

Judaica & Israel Gifts
Jewish Gifts: Judaica:
Ahava Products

Powered by Blogger

Subscribe to
Posts [Atom]

RSS V 1.0

International Affairs Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory